An International Pain Classification System: How Reliable Are the Assessments Across Different Raters?

2011 Jan 1

01/01/2011

PubMed:

Journal of Pain and Symptom Management ; 41(1):196-197.

By Nekolaichuk C, Fainsinger R, Spruyt, O, Galloway, L, Fisch M, Kaye G, Hanson J, Bruera E, Zhukovsky D, Landman W, Bercovitch M, Lawlo P.

Background. There is no universally accepted system to accurately predict complexity of cancer pain management. The Edmonton Classification System for Cancer Pain (ECS-CP) was developed from the Edmonton Staging System (ESS) for Cancer Pain (1989) and the revised ESS (rESS) (2005). This study is an extension of an international multicenter validation study of the ECS-CP.

Research objectives. The primary objective was to estimate the reliability of ratings for the five ECS-CP features (ie, pain mechanism, incident pain, psychological distress, addictive behavior, cognitive function) using different raters across diverse palliative care services.

Methods. Eleven-hundred patients were recruited from 11 specialist palliative care sites (inpatient and outpatient palliative consult services, tertiary palliative care units, hospice settings) located in Canada, USA, Ireland, Israel, Australia and New Zealand (100 per site). A palliative care specialist completed the ECS-CP for each referred cancer patient. Additional information, including daily patient pain ratings, was recorded until study endpoint (ie, stable pain control, discharge, death). At six sites, two raters independently completed the pain classification system within 24 hours of each other (n = 338). Intra-class correlations were used to calculate interrater reliability estimates across all sites.

Results. 944/1100 patients had a pain syndrome (86%); 338/944 (36%) involved two independent raters. Interrater reliability estimates, in descending order, were: pain mechanism 0.81 (95% CI .77–.84), cognitive function 0.72 (95% CI .66-.77), incident pain 0.67 (95% CI .61-.72), addictive behavior, 0.64 (95% CI .57-.70) and psychological distress 0.52 (95% CI .44-.59). Comparisons between these estimates and interrater reliability estimates from a previous ECS-CP validation study will be presented.

Conclusion. The variability across raters, particularly for incident pain, addictive behavior and psychological distress, highlight the complexity of assessing these features.

More publications on the subject

PALLIATIVE SOCIAL WORK IN ISRAEL – CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES

01/06/2022

Abstract Israel, a young country that constantly absorbs immigrants from different cultures, has a unique social structure. The mosaic of culture and values that

Adapting a palliative care-focused cancer self- and family management intervention for use in Israel

01/08/2022

Abstract Background: In Israel, there is a need to improve quality of life and health outcomes among patients and families facing cancer. Increasing awareness of,

Do Perceptions about Palliative Care Affect Emergency Decisions of Health Personnel for Patients with Advanced Dementia?

01/08/2022

Abstract Decision analysis regarding emergency medical treatment in patients with advanced dementia has seldom been investigated. We aimed to examine the preferred medical treatment

Identifying patients in need of palliative care: Adaptation of the Necesidades Paliativas CCOMS-ICO© (NECPAL) screening tool for use in Israel

01/02/2024

Abstract Objectives: The Necesidades Paliativas CCOMS-ICO© (NECPAL) screening tool was developed to identify patients in need of palliative care and has been used in Israel

Palliative team involvement in end-of-life care for Jewish and Muslim children in Jerusalem: A unique clinical and cultural context

01/02/2024

Abstract Objectives: Pediatric palliative care services improve the quality of life for children with life-limiting and life-threatening diseases, although little has been published about variation

Death education for Palliative care: a european project for University students

21/04/2023

Abstract Background: The need to spread the culture of palliative care and to train health care professionals from undergraduate courses is recognised internationally. The article